Cookie Review: Pepperidge Farm 2!

Okay, so they were on sale at Ralphs!

I got the Snickerdoodles:

Pepperidge Farm Snickerdoodle Cookie

So I had a craving for some cinnamon sugar. Sue me.

I couldn’t even wait until I got home to open the bag (hey, I just did 35 minutes of cardio!) and eagerly bit into the self-proclaimed soft baked cookie. I suppose there is a difference between soft cookie and soft baked? Not to say that these were crunchy, but they were harder than I expected. I’ll have to be honest, it was a little disappointing. Not enough cinnamon, a bit too much sugar and much too hard. Have you ever picked up a glass of what you thought was Coke and took a sip only to find out it was Sprite (or even more surprising, water)? Okay, maybe it wasn’t that drastic of a surprise, but I expected better. I’ll have to stick to my normal chocolate chip mac and white choc mac, BUT, the Molasses cookie looks really good too…

If you get this cookie, I STRONGLY recommend you stick it in the microwave for about 8 seconds. It makes for a much softer cookie, and it tastes SO much better because it’s warm :)

  • Taste: 7
  • Crust moistness: medium (5) when I wanted soft (1-3 would have done great; 1 coming out of the microwave)
  • Center moistness: ditto for crust moistness
  • Value: large cookies on the average, $3 for a pack of 8 on sale, not bad, 10
  • Overall: won’t purchase again with the other options out there from PF. 5.

What do you think? Are tough snickerdoodles your thing?

Bookmark and Share
No Comment


Leave a comment